By Jadyn White, The House of Huntley · Updated November 2026
Parrot Cay vs Ambergris Cay: the short answer
Turks and Caicos has two private island resorts that most travelers weigh against each other: COMO Parrot Cay, off the coast between Providenciales and North Caicos, and Ambergris Cay, to the southeast near South Caicos. Both give you an island shared only with other resort guests, but they feel quite different.
In the Parrot Cay vs Ambergris Cay decision, the simplest distinction is this. Parrot Cay is a wellness-led resort with one of COMO's original Shambhala retreats, reached by boat. Ambergris Cay is an all-inclusive island reached by a short private flight, with every residence given its own pool and golf cart. One is about restoration and refinement, the other about ease and space.
How do you get to Parrot Cay and Ambergris Cay?
Parrot Cay has no airstrip or causeway. Guests are usually met at Providenciales airport, driven to a dock in Leeward on the east end of the island, and taken across by the resort's boat, a crossing of roughly 30 minutes. The arrival by water is part of the appeal.
Ambergris Cay is reached by air. After landing at Providenciales, guests transfer to the Atlantic Aviation private terminal and take a flight of about 20 minutes to the island's own airport. Its runway of roughly 5,700 feet can take large private jets, and on-island customs and immigration are available for private arrivals, so a private jet can fly straight to the island without stopping on Providenciales.
COMO Parrot Cay: what the stay is like
Parrot Cay covers roughly 1,000 acres, with most of its north coast given to a single long beach and the south side to mangroves. Rooms and suites sit in the main resort, while standalone beach villas of one to five bedrooms have private pools and butler service. A small number of larger private homes on the island are also available for groups.
Dining centers on The Terrace, with Mediterranean cooking, and Lotus by the pool, with Asian dinners and Caribbean lunches, plus the COMO Beach Club. The COMO Shambhala retreat sits on the far side of the island from the accommodation, with treatment pavilions over the North Caicos Channel, a yoga pavilion, a Pilates studio and a Jacuzzi garden.
Because the island is reached only by boat, days settle into an easy rhythm: a yoga class or a swim in the morning, the long beach through the middle of the day and a treatment in the late afternoon. Guests who want more activity can arrange boat trips into the surrounding cays.
Ambergris Cay: what the stay is like
Ambergris Cay spans more than 1,100 acres, and more than 60 percent of it is preserved as habitat, including for the endangered Turks and Caicos rock iguana. There are 31 beachfront bungalows and private villas, the largest with up to 11 bedrooms. Every one has a private pool, a dedicated island host and an electric golf cart for getting around.
The rate covers meals, premium drinks and non-motorized water sports such as kayaking, paddleboarding and Hobie Cat sailing, along with tennis, pickleball, fitness and yoga. Spa treatments, diving, motorized water sports and private dining are arranged on top. There is no dive operation on the island itself, but the concierge can book trips with nearby operators, as well as fishing, whale watching from January to April, and sunset cruises.
Which private island is better for families or couples?
Both islands welcome children. Ambergris Cay runs the Explorer's Hut for ages 5 to 12, and its villas and golf carts make it very easy with a group of mixed ages. At Parrot Cay, the Play by COMO program and babysitting look after younger guests, while the island's quieter, spa-centered rhythm tends to suit couples and adults especially well.
- Choose Parrot Cay for yoga, spa time, a boat arrival and a more classic resort atmosphere.
- Choose Ambergris Cay for an all-inclusive stay, private-jet convenience and large villas for families or friends.
- Choose either over Grace Bay when the point of the trip is to see very few people.
Other quiet islands to know
South Caicos has become the third option for travelers who want distance from Providenciales. Sailrock South Caicos offers suites and villas within a large residential resort community, and the island now has nonstop flights from Miami on American Airlines and, from December 20, 2026, seasonal BermudAir service from Newark.
Pine Cay, in the chain of cays east of Providenciales, is a private inhabited island with its own small airstrip, and several other cays are uninhabited and can be visited by boat for a day. A Waldorf Astoria has been announced for Dellis Cay, next to Parrot Cay, with opening targeted for 2028, so it is not yet a choice for near-term trips.
How long should you stay on a private island?
Because each island takes a transfer to reach, I usually suggest at least five nights, and seven if you are crossing time zones or traveling with children. Many guests split a trip: a few nights on Grace Bay for restaurants and easy beach days, then the island for the second half, when the pace naturally slows.
Over Christmas and New Year, expect longer minimum stays. Ambergris Cay, for example, asks for seven nights for arrivals across the late December and early January holiday period.
How we plan it
I begin by asking how you want to arrive and how you want to spend the days, since that usually decides between a boat to Parrot Cay and a flight to Ambergris Cay. From there I match the villa or bungalow to your group and confirm what is included and what to reserve ahead, such as spa time or a dive day.
I coordinate the airport meet, the boat or the island flight, and, for private jets, the arrival plan with your flight department, so the hand-offs are seamless from landing to the villa door.
Planning a trip? See the full guide to Turks and Caicos or apply for membership.